Forums expert advice

Tech Blog

  • Register
  • ·
  • Sign In
  • ·
  • Help

eBooks - not quite there yet.

by on 06-02-2010 10:46 AM

Recently I bought a simple eBook reader online. My wife has one too, from a different manufacturer. All’s good; they both work great and make it easier to read books in situations where turning pages is harder than pressing a button (on the treadmill, for example). It’s also great to have a nice light device that I can carry with me in a form-factor thinner than most paperbacks.

Or should I say, almost all’s good; unlike a physical book, we can’t share our purchased eBooks between our two different devices easily. Even if they’re in the ‘portable’ ePub format.

ePub is a common eBook format that’s actually a ‘container’ for the content that’s supposed to be device agnostic -- any ePub is supposed to be viewable on any eReader that can view ePubs -- desktops, portable, iPhone, etc. But ePub also has the ability to be encrypted. Which breaks the portability. ePub for books is not the same as mp3 for music.

Many eBook publishers and vendors choose to use ePub encryption, which ties the purchase of your eBook to you by wrapping the book in unique encryption that is coded to your eBook purchase transaction.

If I try to copy her ePub book to my reader, the book doesn’t display. The reader won’t recognize it because it can’t decrypt the text. Which is kinda silly because if I buy a physical book and read it, I can hand it to my wife to read at any time. Not so with ePub encrypted eBooks.

Sure, there are ways to strip the encryption from ePubs, but that’s not the point. eBooks and eReaders are trying to evolve the experience and custom of reading, bringing it to the 21st century.

They’re failing, because the custom and expectation of being able to share a book is not being honoured. And until it is, eBooks won’t gain the popularity that physical books have. As with the music industry, eBook publishers will have to forget the last-century thinking of locking down their content and develop ways and business models that allow their customers to share their eBooks, and really evolve the experience.




Comments
by Katharine (anon) on 06-02-2010 06:18 PM

It seems such short-term thinking, too. As things stand, if I decide to move from, say, a Kindle to a Nook, I'd have to repurchase my books, because the Nook wouldn't be able to read Kindle's encryption. It also seems to be a thorny problem for our conventional notions about libraries.

There are some problems to be worked out with this. I very much want an e-reader, but I'm delaying a purchase until some of the DRM problems get shaken out, and until I see how the tablet market develops, as I'd prefer to have an e-reader that offered some additional functionality.

Actually, what I really wanted for an e-reader was Microsoft's Courier, but we saw what happened with that.

by Tony212 on 06-02-2010 11:37 PM

I have a Kindle, however I am in the process of selling it. Ebook readers are most definitely the way of the future. In light of this, I have decided to let social technology catch back up with me. Ebook readers are drastically overpriced for the product and I will be waiting to buy my Ebook reader when the price is closer to the $50 range, which I believe it will be in 2 years or so.

On to the topic at hand.  Ironically, I believe piracy is the solution to the concern. Sooner or later someone will take the time and convert the books to a universal format such as PDF or other reasonable format. More and more books will be converted by the sharing community until those that purchase their books such as bgrier and Katherine become fed up with the unreasonable methods of service delivery by publishers. Hopefully publishers will realize that pirates will be pirates and customers will be customers and remove the senseless restrictions.

by on 06-03-2010 09:33 AM

@Katharine: Hopefully the problem is short-term too. There are more eReaders entering the marketplace, and as more units are sold, pressure from consumers will be to eliminate DRM.

@Tony212: Good points. Pricepoint will drop, hopefully to $50, but then, hardware MFGs may just keep adding features to keep the pricepoint higher.

Pirates will be pirates, and likely break the DRM and repost the DRM free version. Customers will buy the DRM'd version and be frustrated that they can't migrate their library to a New device they buy to replace an older one. DRM punishes the honest.

by Tony212 on 06-04-2010 12:55 PM

You got it bgrier. I completely agree with you.

Like the sucker I am I will pay the extra for the added features.  The big one I am waiting for, that hasn't been announced as far as I know, is a dual e-ink/back-lit ebook reader.  Providing the option of reading with natural light as well as in the dark when necessary.

by on 06-04-2010 01:53 PM

Yeah, there's nothing backlit with eInk...though the Notion Ink technology looks pretty cool if it can make it to a dedicated reader, and not stay bundled in a slate/tablet device.

Post a Comment
Be sure to enter a unique name. You can't reuse a name that's already in use.
Be sure to enter a unique email address. You can't reuse an email address that's already in use.
  • Rich Text
  • HTML
  • Preview
Quote Spell Check
Type the characters you see in the picture above. Type the words you hear.
About Tech Blog

How-tos, reviews, tech news & commentary straight from our bloggers:

buzzbishop
gadgets, apps, social media & lifestyle
PaulH
gaming
trishussey
software, hardware, photography, gadgets & home office
bgrier
software, hardware, photography, mobile, mp3/iPods & social media
MathewKumar
gaming & movies
klausboedker
photography
TimR
music & movies
Graham
home theatre, appliances, photography, cellular, gaming & home office
Elliott
appliances, gaming & mobile
MikeYawney
home theatre, mobile, gaming, gadgets, photography
TeddyK
software, hardware, the web, gaming, photography & gadgets
Krypto
wireless

Interested in contributing to the Tech Blog? Apply now to become a guest blogger!

Labels
  • 3DTV (10)
  • (1)
  • appliances (4)
  • apps (17)
  • (1)
  • cameras & camcorders (78)
  • car audio & gps (6)
  • (3)
  • cell phones (2)
  • (3)
  • ces2010 (20)
  • ces2010interviews (9)
  • ces2010news (12)
  • ces2010productreviews (7)
  • communication (42)
  • computer & laptop hardware (45)
  • computer & laptop software (57)
  • (1)
  • e3 2009 (22)
  • (1)
  • gadgets (58)
  • gaming (224)
  • green (8)
  • guest blogger (3)
  • hardware (8)
  • (1)
  • home office (76)
  • home theatre (30)
  • how-to (26)
  • internet (55)
  • (3)
  • iPad (18)
  • iphone (7)
  • iphone4 (1)
  • ipods & mp3 players (30)
  • microsoft xbox & xbox 360 (82)
  • (6)
  • movies (39)
  • music (22)
  • new release (1)
  • news (65)
  • nintendo ds wii & gamecube (52)
  • opinion (20)
  • (3)
  • (39)
  • (2)
  • PMA2010 (27)
  • ps3 (3)
  • (1)
  • social media (33)
  • social networking (1)
  • software (16)
  • sony playstation (79)
  • tablet (11)
  • tech tips (20)
  • technology (9)
  • the web (7)
  • tv (31)
  • twitter (1)
  • (1)
  • WES2010 (7)
  • wireless (2)
  • wwdc (3)
  • xbox 360 (9)
  • « Previous
  • Next »
Latest Articles
  • Batman Under the Red Hood gets Future Shop-exclu si...
  • Your DS, DSi, or DSi XL just got a little more cla...
  • Score: FIFA World Cup in 3D thanks to cable provid...
  • No Official World Cup App?
  • iBooks could convert me, only if...
  • I'm Sorry, What!? Zeno Clash: Ultimate Edition
  • Second thoughts on Apples upcoming iOS4 operating ...
  • Safari5 is the awesome part of WWDC you can use no...
  • Apple WWDC Keynote Live Blog
  • Microsoft Canada's Mission 4 Miracles Announceme nt
Latest Comments
Top Kudoed Authors
User Kudos Count
5
4
2
1
1
View All